“These White Gay Guys Are Coming To Take All Our Jobs.” Workplace Discrimination In The Mayor’s Office.

My name is James Felton Keith. I’m from Detroit Michigan. I moved back home in 2014 to work for the newly elected mayor of Detroit. A few days before I was supposed to start work on a Monday I was asked to come in on Friday to kind of get an ID badge and meet some of the team and get a feel for the office that I would be working in. The first person I met was this fairly tall brown-skinned woman with shiny gray hair. It was like platinum. And she had the sweetest up-do. It looked kind of like a few of my aunts, kind of like my grandmother’s hair. She’s just cool. She was excited that I was there because at this time it was the first white mayor that Detroit had since 1974 and they were happy for as many black staff to come back or talent to come back into the city. I was sitting, getting ready to take my picture for my badge. This is early in the morning, this is about thirty minutes to an hour after I first met my new auntie. These two white gay guys came into the office to get their badges. And she introduced me to them, it was very cordial, very professional. The two guys leave, they leave the room. She nudges me and says, “You know, these white gay guys are coming to take all our jobs.” And my first reaction was to kind of smirk or laugh but I knew that it was wrong. I was also in the city to assume the role as the president of the new newly-established LGBT Chamber of Commerce. And having to kind of wear my truth on my sleeve, I let her know that I’m also here to work with the LGBT Chamber of Commerce. And she paused and said, you know, like, “You too?” I say, “Yeah, I’m with them.” And she said, “Oh, you know it’s fine, it’s fine. I was just saying, I was just letting you know that, you know, they’re here and they’re getting a lot of these jobs. You know what I mean.” So during my time in the administration, I agreed to take an interview in the mayor’s office with their LGBT media which was a magazine called Pridesource. And during Pride week I also agreed to go to all the Pride events available. I posted quite a few pictures on Instagram. And that was that. It just felt like a regular weekend. I came back into work that next Monday, late in the day about three o’clock. And when I came back into the 11th floor where the mayor’s office is, I pulled out my key fob, I tried to get into the doors that I would normally have access to and nothing was happening. But I didn’t think anything of it because you know, city government, and you just think stuff breaks, right? I can always go through the reception to get to my auntie’s office and I go to holler at her and see what’s happening for the day. While I’m in her office, the chief counsel pops his head into the office and asks if we can, you know, have a quick rap. We pop out for a minute and we go into another office and it’s just him and the chief of staff and they’re both sitting there and it’s a very serious atmosphere. He just slammed his hand on the table, you know, gently but kind of slams his hand on the table and says, “It’s not working out.” And I thought, “What do you mean it’s not working out? It’s working out. The strategy that I came there to implement was working out.” And so he told me that my associations weren’t aligned with the administration. And that’s specifically what he said. I will never forget it. And I walked out of the office. They said that they would escort me back to my desk and I shouldn’t go back and get my key from my new auntie’s office. And I think that was the first time that I ever felt like someone was calling me a faggot and meant it. Because in my life I hadn’t really experienced that where someone meant it. My only assumptions are that I was bad for strategy, that I was going to cause them to have communications issues, or that I was going to cause them to have to talk about issues that they didn’t want to have to talk about in the first six months. Because that was the extent of my tenure. I was there for just those first six months. It helped me own my identity and so something that I had thought that I was out about, I realized I was slightly ashamed about that I questioned when I was first confronted with a homophobic statement on those first days or even when I was confronted about my association on those last days, going in my mind about, “Oh I shouldn’t have said this, I shouldn’t have been that out.” All those thoughts crossed my mind but at the end of the day, I think, the most valuable thing that happened was, I got to own myself, I got to own my own identity. And there’s a new sort of comfort that comes with that.

James Felton Keith


  1. When it comes to elected politics, there are appointments and lifetime workers. Most new administrations that replace an old one, do have the right to fill spots with their own appointments. Sometimes,if there is a death of the elected official, some are kept on until the new person has adapted, and that new person then picks his own administration. This is common,especially in city,state and federal positions. If you feel you were replaced unfairly because you are gay,or black and can prove it,then file a complaint. I’ve been involved in the gay rights movement for 40 years. I remember when Mayor Moscone was elected, and his first appointment was Harvey Milk, to the Board of Permits. However, Harvey betrayed Mayor Moscone trust when he decided to run against a sitting elected fellow Democrat, Art Agnost, who was also a friend to the S.F. gay community,and the Mayor asked him to resign,and he did.

    I have found in those 40+ years, that there are heterophobic gays,too. It’s a 2 way street sometimes. There is an old adage, if you can not stand the heat in a political kitchen, then stay out. I always considered myself as a middle of the road political thinker, but recall President Eisenhower saying that taking a political stance in the middle of the road, will open you up to the extremes of both sides of a political issue.

  2. Thanks for being comfortable in your beautiful skin nephew.

  3. Pingback: This Man Found Workplace Discrimination in a Big City Mayor’s Office -

  4. The government is usually the biggest source of discrimination and all the other problems of the world that the government so kindly claims are problems after they create the problem. More power to you him but I would never consider working there even if it does mean being homeless and hungry.

    He should have used better strategy and kept quiet about it while silently working to destroy this woman and sabotaging her every effort. The fact is that SHE messed up BIG TIME by saying those things and she knew it when he called her out on it. That’s why I always make it a point to be careful what I say to someone because you never know who you’re talking to or how what you say may result in your failure. Especially if you’re in a small town where people hire their family members and everybody knows everybody else and they all have their personal vendettas you have to exercise extreme caution.

    “Speak ill of no man, but speak all the good you know of everybody.” -Benjamin Franklin

Comments are closed